Page 1 of 3
Chris Judd. season over? career over?
Posted: Sat Jun 06, 2015 2:24 pm
by melliot
Looks like he just did his ACL.
Hate the Blues. But not the way you like to see any player end a career, yet a champ and a generational player like Judd.
Posted: Sat Jun 06, 2015 2:30 pm
by HAL
Interesting comparsion.
Posted: Sat Jun 06, 2015 3:14 pm
by Wokko
That'll be all she wrote. Off into the sunset with his brown paper bags and career regret of a move to Carlton when he could've played during the prime Malthouse era at Collingwood.
Posted: Sat Jun 06, 2015 3:15 pm
by GreekLunatic
he played one season too long
Posted: Sat Jun 06, 2015 4:33 pm
by Piesnchess
Hes gawn, such is life, and visy, dodgy brown paper bags, cheating, and a 0-5 record v the Pies under his former coach at west coast. Thats the way it is, que sera, sera.
Posted: Sat Jun 06, 2015 4:42 pm
by Flashman
Great, great footballer who turned the game on its head when he first burst on the scene.
His stats for his first 100 games were superior to Fyfe and anyone else you care to name and included a Brownlow, Norm Smith and a premiership.
His move to Carlton to escape the toxic West Coast culture may in hindsight be seen as a mistake by both parties but no one can deny he gave them tremendous service. He became a harder inside mid from necessity due to the dearth of quality midfielders compared to the Weagles and while not as spectacular as during his halcyon Perth days he was still an undeniably great player.
It's always sad to see a champion bow out in this manner irrespective of who they play for.
Posted: Sat Jun 06, 2015 4:46 pm
by Doc63
Piesnchess wrote:Hes gawn, such is life, and visy, dodgy brown paper bags, cheating, and a 0-5 record v the Pies under his former coach at west coast. Thats the way it is, que sera, sera.
He's not that old!!
His first game was against us in Round 2, 2002 at the MCG.
Posted: Sat Jun 06, 2015 4:53 pm
by DT
Saw his first game against the Pies and you could see he was a star. Great shame he went to such a rotten basket case club for the second half of his career
Posted: Sat Jun 06, 2015 5:01 pm
by swoop42
He's not the good bloke people try to make him out to be as the chicken wing, eye gouging and other incidents have shown.
Posted: Sat Jun 06, 2015 5:55 pm
by Flashman
Doc63 wrote:Piesnchess wrote:Hes gawn, such is life, and visy, dodgy brown paper bags, cheating, and a 0-5 record v the Pies under his former coach at west coast. Thats the way it is, que sera, sera.
He's not that old!!
His first game was against us in Round 2, 2002 at the MCG.
I was there and he was bloody near BOG in that game as well.
We won a thriller with Brodie Holland kicking an amazing 8 goals (I can't recall any Pies player kicking as many in a game since) in a really good game.
As we left though I remember talking to my mate about how friggin good that kid Judd looked. Jeez that time has just flown.
Posted: Sat Jun 06, 2015 5:58 pm
by Doc63
Flashman wrote:Doc63 wrote:Piesnchess wrote:Hes gawn, such is life, and visy, dodgy brown paper bags, cheating, and a 0-5 record v the Pies under his former coach at west coast. Thats the way it is, que sera, sera.
He's not that old!!
His first game was against us in Round 2, 2002 at the MCG.
I was there and he was bloody near BOG in that game as well.
We won a thriller with
Brodie Holland kicking an amazing 8 goals (I can't recall any Pies player kicking as many in a game since) in a really good game.
As we left though I remember talking to my mate about how friggin good that kid Judd looked. Jeez that time has just flown.
He kicked 5 of them in the first quarter, if I remember correctly.
Posted: Sat Jun 06, 2015 6:18 pm
by stui magpie
Flashman wrote:Great, great footballer who turned the game on its head when he first burst on the scene.
His stats for his first 100 games were superior to Fyfe and anyone else you care to name and included a Brownlow, Norm Smith and a premiership.
His move to Carlton to escape the toxic West Coast culture may in hindsight be seen as a mistake by both parties but no one can deny he gave them tremendous service. He became a harder inside mid from necessity due to the dearth of quality midfielders compared to the Weagles and while not as spectacular as during his halcyon Perth days he was still an undeniably great player.
It's always sad to see a champion bow out in this manner irrespective of who they play for.
Yeah, good summary.
the Wiggles set up to let him use his attributes but you still have to be able to do it, and the fact that he had to change his game significantly at Carlton shows what a good player he was.
Shitty way to finish a career, but unfortunately probably appropriate given how Carton have been going.
Posted: Sat Jun 06, 2015 6:34 pm
by Dave The Man
Good Thing for Scum as they can play more Kids now.
Judd be Wasting his Time at a Club that is so far away from Finals Footy
Posted: Sat Jun 06, 2015 6:48 pm
by i hate carlton
Now he can sit at home and eat Chicken Wings.
Filthy player. Carlscum through and through.
Posted: Sat Jun 06, 2015 7:22 pm
by Bob Sugar
i hate carlton wrote:Now he can sit at home and eat Chicken Wings.
Filthy player. Carlscum through and through.
Ease up mate, let's not temp karma shall we?
I don't like him, but I hate to see champions end like that.