Pre-Match: Pies v. Roos ... all comments here...

[Heater_39]

This is how I'd like to see it.

IN:

Scott Burns
Tyson Goldsack
Chris Egan

OUT:
Danny Stanley
Alan Toovey
Nick Maxwell (susp)


Reasoning - Toovey not AFL standard, Stanley not there yet, Maxwell gone for that elbow. Burnsy to come in and give some grunt in the middle, Egan pace and Goldsack comes back a week too late. Shane O'Bree will be lucky to get a game after that performance today!

[virgomag]

If Goldsack still isn't right then i'd like to see Jack Anthony or Chris Dawes (for Maxwells holiday).

Toovey and Stanley out with hopefully Burns and Iles in for me.

[The Great Dane]

Agree with your heater_39, but with your ins, i would put holland or reid in, if they are fit

[Kingswood]

interesting with egan,

but i imagine the game next week will be suited to him...inject some pace...

i wanna see wellingham get a shot and wouldnt mind seeing cox get a call up...

definately thouhg Goldsack coming back is a must..

The other question is what to do with marty?? he seems to have taken a backwards step this year. he is my favourite player and im really worried about him

[TMan4]

Are you serious about Egan? He's softer than a 90 year old mans flacid penis. I'd bring in Burns and Goldsack and maybe Anthony. Stanley and Toovey aren't AFL standard. All round bad perfoimances today so we'll see next week which Collingwood turns up.

[eddiesmith]

In: Lonie, Anthony, Cox

Out: Stanley, Toovey, Maxwell

[Fire Up]

wouldnt mind seeing holland and anthony with goldsack and burns in.

stanley and toovey have to go.

if its good enough for mm to drop anthony after 1 good game its good enough for him to delist toovey by year end for a sh!t game/s

[leonmagic]

leave stanley in, how about you actually give a kid more than a game to find his feet? jesus

toovey must go, just an awkward looking player. not good enough.

in: burns, goldsack
out: toovey, maxwell (susp)

no need to swing the axe too much.

[RudeBoy]

Definite ins (if fit): Burns, Goldsack

Definite outs: Stanley, Toovey

I would make 2 other changes as well to sharpen up our whole team.

Ins: Cox, Wellingham
Outs: Maxwell (likely suspended), Johnno

[HAL]

leave stanley in, how about you actually give a kid more than a game to find his feet? jesus

toovey must go, just an awkward looking player. not good enough.

in: burns, goldsack
out: toovey, maxwell (susp)

no need to swing the axe too much.

What's wrong, attempting medhurts style?

[Peter]

In: Brodie, Sacky and Burns

out:

Toovey, Stanley and Maxy...

Call me Crazy but Fraser may not be far away.....

[Dave The Man]

IN: Goldsack Cox(Anthony or Reid)

Out: Toovey Stanley Maxwell

[Piethagoras' Theorem]

In: VFL Magpies

Out: Everyone! Including coaches

[Fire Up]

leave stanley in, how about you actually give a kid more than a game to find his feet? jesus

toovey must go, just an awkward looking player. not good enough.

in: burns, goldsack
out: toovey, maxwell (susp)

no need to swing the axe too much.

if its good enough for anthony to be dropped after 1 good game its good enough for stanley to be dropped.

you have to admit anthony played better in his 1st game then what stanley did today

[Didcos435]

In - Burns, Goldsack, Reid (however unlikely)

Out - Maxwell (susp), Stanley and Toovey

Time to bring Reid in and leave him there to give us our 3rd tall avenue to goal. He is quick, good hands on the lead and highly talented. Unleash him. However I expect him to be playing in the VFL Brown and Anthony are defenders.

Anthony may get another crack at it.