Post match. PIES wallop Dogs - All comments

[Donny]

Maggies by 49 points.

Let's hear about it !!

[Jarryd]

Not the best game of all time. Pies will be struggling to name 22 blokes next week with the amount of injuries and possible reports out of this game.

[Eunos]

Someone forgot to tell CFC about the tactic of the TANK, and how to apply it.

[sdmonkey82]

Despite all the injuries i fail to see how Shane O'Bree could be in our best 22 next week.

Good effort by the boys though, it was nice to see Walker get some touches.

[commonwombat]

Our coaching staff failed basic Panzer tactics 101. Dummkopfs !!!

[foxychick]

sdmonkey 82 shane o bree played alright he certainly wasn't the worst. But he did do some nice things. He did rack up around 17 posi's or so, that's an improved effort from recent weeks!
Lets just enjoy the win! Although, the injuries are a worry....I don't think Williamstown will have much of a Senior team by next week GO PIES!

[Johnson#26]

Great win. Finally we ran out a game.

Good: Bucks, Burns, Farse, Tex.

Bad: O'B.

[maggies2003]

Player Ratings:

Buckley - 8/10 - Classy game by the skipper..

Burns - 7/10 - Started Well, faded a bit as the game went on..

Clement - 7/10 - Another consistent game..

Cloke - 5/10 - OK, did a few good things..

Cole - 5/10 - Pretty Good, defended well..

Davis - 6/10 - did well..seemed to get injured late tho..

Fraser - 8/10 - Great game, did a hell of alot of work..

Holland - 6/10 - Didnt get much of a run, but found the ball when he did.

Johnson - 8.5/10 - Best On, tremendous run..

King - 2/10 - rarely cited, kicked a great goal..

Licuria - 6/10 - Pretty good game, moved onto west late but couldnt stop him..

Lockyer - 5/10 - Got alot of the ball, but time and time again he doesnt put his body on the line..

Lokan - 4/10 - Did well when given a go.

Lonie - 4/10 - Did Ok, doesnt run as much as he used to..

Maxwell - 5/10 - Great game, puts his body on the line,..

McKee - 6/10 - his presence was enough..

Obree - 4/10 - Too many times he turns it over..

Presti - ??? - Was best on before he went iff early..

Rowe - 2/10 - The kid has guts, but no foot skills..

Shaw - 6/10 - did another great tagging job..

Walker - 5/10 - His presence was good, did well..

Woey - 5/10 - didnt play as he normally does... did ok though..

Votes:
3 - Johnno
2 - Fraser
1 - Buckley

..cheers...

[Mick's My Favourite]

the worst game I ever saw...

except for the Pies last 10 minutes.

[foreigner]

I guess you haven't been watcing any games this year MMF if you call this the worst game you ever saw ... no wait ... you haven't been watching Collinwood for the last 10 years or so.

[LeonMcS]

At one stage during the last quarter when we were 15 points up and the game in the balance, I found myself humming the tune from F Troop as we advanced forward in a desperate scramble of mis-timed passes.
Dogs kicking as they did helped.
Still, valuable game time for a lot of the young guys and Richards, though inaccurate had some presence. Promising signs...
And the last goal of the night, marking contest, Bucks vs 3, creates the contest and the ball clears to Lonie while Bucks has taken all 3 Bulldogs out of the play, great work!

[Dale61]

LeonMcS wrote:

Still, valuable game time for a lot of the young guys and Richards, though inaccurate had some presence.

Richards, eh! Surely you mean Tex?

[Dr Alf Andrews]

Scoreboard flattered us. That game was in doubt 20 minutes into last quarter. Then a flood of goals in junk time.

I reckon the Bulldogs would have won if Darcy (in particular) could have kicked straight.

Inspirational work from Buckley.
Promising stuff from Tex.
Burns magnificent.
Fraser magnificent.
Shaw might have saved his career with that effort (not sure if I'm pleased about that)
Lonie made some important contributions.

All in all ... given the long absentee list ... I would say it was a very pleasing start to our 2005 pre-season.

[Canberra]

sdmonkey 82 shane o bree played alright he certainly wasn't the worst. But he did do some nice things. He did rack up around 17 posi's or so, that's an improved effort from recent weeks!
Lets just enjoy the win! Although, the injuries are a worry....I don't think Williamstown will have much of a Senior team by next week GO PIES!

17 possessions and about 8 turnovers. His kicking is a disgrace.

[magpies are 2 good]

good win by the magpies BUT we were lucky if the bulldogs kicked straight for goals it would of been a different story. for the bulldogs to get within 1 goal of us i think in the 4th quater just shows were we are at the moment!!!