Page 3 of 4
Re: Jeremy Cameron, think again....
Posted: Wed Nov 11, 2020 2:05 pm
by Presti35
Geelong has traded 2 more younger players out today;
Nakia Cockatoo (Pick 10, 2014) to Brisbane in return for a future third-round selection (tied to Melbourne).
Lachie Fogarty (Pick 22, 2017) and a second-round pick (currently No.38) to Carlton in return for a second-round pick (currently No.30) and a third-round pick (currently No.51).
Fogarty has had 2 injury interrupted seasons and Cockatoo has struggled to get into the team.
Looking back at drafts between 2014-2018, they've traded out a lot of those players picked.
Promising young players, 23 and under:
Jordan Clark, 19 (Linked to WCE/Freo. Likely to stay now)
Cooper Stephens, 20
Sam De Koning, 20
Charlie Constable, 21 (Asked to look for another club. Essendon linked early on)
Gryan Miers, 21
Esava Ratugolea, 22 (Linked to GWS, but turned down)
Brandan Parfitt, 22 (Wanted by GWS)
Sam Simpson, 22
Jack Henry, 22
Zach Guthrie, 22
Quinton Narkle, 23 (Linked to WCE/Freo. Likely to stay now)
With a trade expected for Higgins and Cameron to come, I wonder if they'll make a surprise move to get some younger tallant in?
If it's not about money, an it's about winning a flag, I dont know if the Cats have long left to get one before they're absolutely screwed.
Posted: Wed Nov 11, 2020 2:22 pm
by Presti35
Pick 30 to North for 33 year old Higgins who is chasing that elusive flag.
Maybe he should have stayed at Footscray then?
Posted: Wed Nov 11, 2020 2:29 pm
by 5 from the wing on debut
Presti35 wrote:Pick 30 to North for 33 year old Higgins who is chasing that elusive flag.
Maybe he should have stayed at Footscray then?
That's generally not a question posed by Collingwood supporters given Buckley and Molloy's experience.
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2020 2:24 pm
by piedys
Hope the trade falls over, and he goes to the draft, and gets taken by Norf.
Re: Jeremy Cameron, think again....
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2020 5:18 pm
by Piesnchess
Presti35 wrote:Geelong has traded 2 more younger players out today;
Nakia Cockatoo (Pick 10, 2014) to Brisbane in return for a future third-round selection (tied to Melbourne).
Lachie Fogarty (Pick 22, 2017) and a second-round pick (currently No.38) to Carlton in return for a second-round pick (currently No.30) and a third-round pick (currently No.51).
Fogarty has had 2 injury interrupted seasons and Cockatoo has struggled to get into the team.
Looking back at drafts between 2014-2018, they've traded out a lot of those players picked.
Promising young players, 23 and under:
Jordan Clark, 19 (Linked to WCE/Freo. Likely to stay now)
Cooper Stephens, 20
Sam De Koning, 20
Charlie Constable, 21 (Asked to look for another club. Essendon linked early on)
Gryan Miers, 21
Esava Ratugolea, 22 (Linked to GWS, but turned down)
Brandan Parfitt, 22 (Wanted by GWS)
Sam Simpson, 22
Jack Henry, 22
Zach Guthrie, 22
Quinton Narkle, 23 (Linked to WCE/Freo. Likely to stay now)
With a trade expected for Higgins and Cameron to come, I wonder if they'll make a surprise move to get some younger tallant in?
If it's not about money, an it's about winning a flag, I dont know if the Cats have long left to get one before they're absolutely screwed.
Cats sure dont believe in a youth policy, do they ?
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2020 5:57 pm
by Presti35
piedys wrote:Hope the trade falls over, and he goes to the draft, and gets taken by Norf.
That would be sensational!
But they might avoid the wooden spoon then.
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2020 7:32 pm
by PyreneesPie
Geelong gets Cameron. How do they pull off these trades?????
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2020 9:29 pm
by Presti35
PyreneesPie wrote:Geelong gets Cameron. How do they pull off these trades?????
With three picks.
Geelongs first pick will be in the 50s.
They have well and truly gone for the all or nothing in 2021. Time will tell if it pays off.
But the media will cast them as heroes until their flag is out of reach, then the media will turn on them.
Posted: Fri Nov 13, 2020 2:55 am
by piedys
PyreneesPie wrote:Geelong gets Cameron. How do they pull off these trades?????
No salary cap to worry about evidently...
Dangerflog
Blicavs
Stewart
Touhey
Menegola
Rohan
Duckwood
Duncan
Dunderklumpen
and now... Cameron, Smith and Higgins
all playing for minimum wage
They've only just shed Ablett, Taylor and Nokia ...
Posted: Sat Nov 28, 2020 4:26 pm
by Jezza
^ Don't they have money left over after trading Kelly last year?
Posted: Sun Apr 11, 2021 4:40 pm
by Presti35
Lachie Fogarty looking like a good pickup for the Blues.
Cameron yet to play for Geelong. Higgins three games and injured.
Scrapped thru vs Adelaide, extremely lucky to beat the Lions, scrapped thru vs Hawthorn, currently playing the Dees.
Early days yet, especially with Dangerfield suspended. But I still think they've sold their future for a crack this year. And they may have missed their chance.
Posted: Sat Sep 11, 2021 12:24 am
by Presti35
What an absolutely crushing defeat.
Can Geelong recover for another crack in 2022?
Posted: Sat Sep 11, 2021 7:30 am
by SwansWay
They’re H&A specialists. I wonder if their home games at Geelong help them make top 4 every year?? I guess that’s worth an extra 4-5 wins per season. Maybe they’re a 7-8 team in reality being flattered by getting easy kills at Skilled Stadium or whatever they call it now.
Posted: Sat Sep 11, 2021 7:38 am
by think positive
Presti35 wrote:What an absolutely crushing defeat.
Can Geelong recover for another crack in 2022?
I’ve said this every year since 2011, and they just keep haunting me. I’m wondering what favours they have left, or if they have handedover all of the negatives, because as the post above said, I know the geefrickenlong lifestyleis a good one, but that looks like some mighty big salary reductions to be able to pull it off.
Posted: Sat Sep 11, 2021 4:03 pm
by Jezza
Chris Scott's record in finals
1. Qualifying Final 2011 vs Hawthorn (W)
2. Preliminary Final 2011 vs West Coast (W)
3. Grand Final 2011 vs Collingwood (W)
4. Elimination Final 2012 vs Fremantle (L)
5. Qualifying Final 2013 vs Fremantle (L)
6. Semi Final 2013 vs Port Adelaide (W)
7. Preliminary Final 2013 vs Hawthorn (L)
8. Qualifying Final 2014 vs Hawthorn (L)
9. Semi Final 2014 vs North Melbourne (L)
10. Qualifying Final 2016 vs Hawthorn (W)
11. Preliminary Final 2016 vs Sydney (L)
12. Qualifying Final 2017 vs Richmond (L)
13. Semi Final 2017 vs Sydney (W)
14. Preliminary Final 2017 vs Adelaide (L)
15. Elimination Final 2018 vs Melbourne (L)
16. Qualifying Final 2019 vs Collingwood (L)
17. Semi Final 2019 vs West Coast (W)
18. Preliminary Final 2019 vs Richmond (L)
19. Qualifying Final 2020 vs Port Adelaide (L)
20. Semi Final 2020 vs Collingwood (W)
21. Preliminary Final 2020 vs Brisbane (W)
22. Grand Final 2020 vs Richmond (L)
23. Qualifying Final 2021 vs Port Adelaide (L)
24. Semi Final 2021 vs GWS (W)
25. Preliminary Final 2021 vs Melbourne (L)
Overall = 10 wins, 15 losses (40.00%)
Overall (excluding 2011) = 7 wins, 15 losses (31.82%)