Pre match: Changes for the Cats game? - All comments here...

[ad4eva]

Cameron Cloke or Richards? It may boil down to Richards having played senior footy this year..Cameron doing ok in the 'seconds'. MM may think that CC may be an occasional option up forward for short bursts...posing then, the dilemna to man him up...and he can kick a goal... or Richards...might be bullied a bit by the likes of Mooney, and King's no pee wee either..Richards is a bit one dimensional...I'd probably give Cameron a shot but it's a toss of MM's coin....Pendleberry to keep waiting

like you said, to create concerns for the Geelong side when you have Trav Cloke (hopefully IMO) Rocca, Tarrant and Cam Cloke all in the one forward line... if its not Cam its Fraser

Cam Cloke for mine

[pietillidie]

I think Tarrant didn't do much last week so we should drop Rocca to teach him a lesson.

Out: Rocca
In: Tristen Walker

LOL

[STOKA35]

for us to win
- keep ottens kingsley ablett jnr quiet
-playfair could be a wild card for them
-break even with king, josh needs to push foward at all times, richards must play to give him a break after last weeks game would have taken its toll
- tarrant and rocca must step up our scorline showed that last week
-use the ball well and move it QUICKLY
-dids we need a big one from you

concerns
-melbourne based teams struggle to win after a trip to perth, i think it will take us a qtr to get going as we will be a bit flat. We need to beat this hoodo adelaide can do it.
-Roccas shoulder how sore is it if he could not lift above his head during the game how would it be after he cooled down.

lets see what happens
pies by 3 points

[burnsy17]

J Cloke is a jinx to the CFC.... we've lost 2 games this year.... i wonder who played in both of those, but none of the 5 wins......

[Jamie loves Collingwood]

In
Buckley
C Cloke
R Shaw

Out
J Cloke
H O'Brien
N Maxwell

If i was coach i'd do this.

[bokka]

I think we have to keep pendles waiting....

next weeks match is perfect for the kid...

we wont need the tall defence because we are up against the bulldogs therefore you would think Wakelin would probabally go out.. Rhyce would come in and probabally Jason ommitted, just for team balance.. therefore Pendles will come in to take on the small,quick bulldogs...

That's pretty good thinking - I was thinking pendles this week but maybe next week a better debut - hopefully if he misses this week they will give him a go against little bullies - provided he plays another blinder in the Willi's.

[3rd degree]

"And pinged with the footy was Rand Corp"

[Clokey]

J Cloke is a jinx to the CFC.... we've lost 2 games this year.... i wonder who played in both of those, but none of the 5 wins......

Hmm I think it might be more the fact he played against good teams.

[melissa]

Yeah, i thought Wakes had a great game! I'd bring in Bucks, C.Cloke and T.Cloke, and omit Harry (he has to go back on rookie list, bloody rules!), Caracella and Jase. Is it just my imagination or did Brodie do stuff all?

[Mossi]

Yeah, i thought Wakes had a great game! I'd bring in Bucks, C.Cloke and T.Cloke, and omit Harry (he has to go back on rookie list, bloody rules!), Caracella and Jase. Is it just my imagination or did Brodie do stuff all?

Brodie was used as a tagger, did his job a little unoticed.
Be great to know the story behind everyone and know what the match committee have in mind. w'ill know soon enough

[Jamie loves Collingwood]

Official!!
In
Nathan Buckley
Cameron Cloke

Out
Jason Cloke
Harry O'Brien

check http://afl.com.au/default.asp?pg=matchd ... ch_id=1615 to see

[Mossi]

Does not look good for Rocca!

[Jamie loves Collingwood]

Why? Rocca is fine! He'll play.

[Mossi]

Why? Rocca is fine! He'll play.

I hope he will be there but with Cam in i get the feeling Rocca won't be lining up!!

[Cannibal]

http://afl.com.au/default.asp?pg=news&s ... eid=266814

COLLINGWOOD
B: Lonie, Prestigiacomo, Clement
HB: H.Shaw, Wakelin, Johnson
C: Caracella, O'Bree, Burns
HF: Didak, Rocca, Davis
F: Thomas, Tarrant, Holland
FOLL: Fraser, Licuria, Buckley
I/C: C.Cloke, Lockyer, Maxwell, Swan
EMG: T.Cloke, Pendlebury, R.Shaw
IN: Buckley, C.Cloke
OUT: J.Cloke, O'Brien
NEW: -

GEELONG
B: Milburn, Scarlett, Mooney
HB: Rooke, Harley, Egan
C: Enright, Bartel, Tenace
HF: G.Ablett, Kingsley, Kelly
F: Playfair, Ottens, Chapman
FOLL: King, Corey, Ling
I/C: S.Johnson, Riccardi, D.Johnson, J.Hunt
EMG: Wojcinski, Mackie, Gardiner
IN: Mooney
OUT: Gardiner
NEW: -

Field umpires: James, Margetts, Ryan