Post match v Aints...all comments here

bwphantom · Post by **bwphantom** » Sat Jul 23, 2005 2:00 pm

Here is the tip guys....

O'bree: not going anywhere...he had OP I reckon and has up until recently come good.
Taz: Knee Cyst my arse...He has OP too I reckon, he is not going anywhere either.
Woey: If anyone says he played a shocker last night must have been watching a different game than me. Keep for another season, on a 1 year performance based contract.
Locky: May look at sending him back to West....But I would delist that slow poke Morrison Before Locky.
Lonie: he had good and bad patches like most playing last night...he will stay.
Williams: Bye bye.
Davidson: unless he plays this season and shows something then needs to be delisted at seasons end.
Fanning: Taken on a big responsibility...just needs to be more accountable for his man.
Buckley: when he went forward our forward line opened up. Just his presence down there demands the oppositions respect. he did stints on the ball but he needs now to focus upon being a forward.
LIcca: If you think we are going to get rid of one of our best for the last few seasons because of a handful of bad games then you have rocks.
Cara: Injured for sure...rest him as it is making him look ordinary.
C1: I thought was solid when on the ground. Would be silly to trade him.
Wakes: Still not running as freely as his normal self. Is it because he is 30, or because he is carrying???
Davis: Our shining light last night. Only player to put his body on the line.
Heater: Impressive, with a lot to learn.
Maxwell: Why continue to play him back, he is a natural forward.
Johnson: Still carrying, can't turn onto his left freely. very obvious by the way he moves.
Clement: Should be made Captain next season. What a Champion. He was giving away height and weight last night, and I would say he won that duel.
Cole: Bye Bye mate.
Yakka: tried hard when on the ground. he will be good for us.
Swan: Has done enought to warrant him to stay.
Lokan: Bye Bye.
Walker: Bye Bye
King: Give him time to get over injury. No good after 06 then march him out.
Richards: If he doesn't play at least 15 games next year then see ya mate.
Fraser: get well mate we miss ya.
Rocca: May become a stay at home forward as his pace may be gone. If not then we need to look at him playing at CHB.
Rusling: Just needs to hold onto those chest marks. keep the elbows in son.
Egan: He actually looked at home up the ground. Deceivably quick.
Didak: A little bit of discipline would not go astray. Puts his body on the line.
Presti: Still good and one of our best defenders.
Rowe: do me a favour mate learn to hit targets.
Holland: would have said at start of season delist him. Now, keep or use as trade.
C2: Lose the Attitude and play footy and will be good.
C3: Keep developing as a CHF.
Morrison: Did not give up much to get him...has not shown or impressed....see ya(but MM won't)
Brent Hall: If does not break in team in 2006...may be showed the door.

I am sure I have missed some.
As for last night?? Considering we had Presti out before the game and players like C2, C3, O'Bree, Rocca, Fraser, Swann, Rowe, Rusling...injured early, Didak...did not come good after hit. I thought we did well to keep within a 100+ drubbin...mainly have Clement to thank for that.

My Votes.
3. Clement
2. Woey
1. Heater, Bux, Tarrant.

PeterWH · Post by **PeterWH** » Sat Jul 23, 2005 2:34 pm

I saw the first 10 minutes of the game and that was enough...this current side is full of sissies....they arent strong they cant pull their weight,they arent interested and i still recon that the local Parkes Panthers & Dubbo Demons....yes these teams actually exist....would be able to beat our guys hands down,
At the end of the season what MANAGEMENT should do is to go right thru the roster and training staff,throw out the dead wood....which is most of the team,check the credentials of the coach,go through the rookie list,then get some players who want to respect and play for the BLACK & WHITE and then hit the paddock,play like MEN and not sissies and win a flag in 2006.
This year has been a disaster right from round 1 and there isnt one player who shouldnt be scrutenised...Except Bucks...... and asked the question....do you want to be here in 2006.
I am ashamed to call myself a PIES supporter at present,BUT I must admit that I have been thru thick and thin since 1965 and I recon that there is more to go.

Forget 2005 now and concentrate of PLAYERS and coaching team for 2006.

Arges Tuft · Post by **Arges Tuft** » Sat Jul 23, 2005 3:23 pm

chris71 wrote: Licuria - running on the spot. This guy has played poor footy for months. May be big trade bait!

I assume if you want to trade Lica - you must have a gas chamber waiting for many of the others?

molloymagic · Post by **molloymagic** » Sat Jul 23, 2005 3:32 pm

If no 1 has said why that st kilda guy got a free kick when Didak and him colided was because Didak put his arms down(channel 9 commentators said if he had kept his arms up then wouldn;t have been a free kick,as it would have been going for the footy).

Keep faith in the pies.

Sultan of spin · Post by **Sultan of spin** » Sat Jul 23, 2005 4:23 pm

bwphantom wrote: Holland: would have said at start of season delist him. Now, keep or use as trade.
.

Obviously a top 5 finish in the copeland last year means nothing then, will finish second this year, anyone who even thiks he will be traded has shit in their head.

Post by **Cam** » Sat Jul 23, 2005 4:32 pm

If Maxwell can play forward and back that is a good thing!!!!! We need blokes who can be switched around if need be.

Proud Pies · Post by **Proud Pies** » Sat Jul 23, 2005 5:01 pm

PeterWH wrote:I saw the first 10 minutes of the game and that was enough...this current side is full of sissies....they arent strong they cant pull their weight,they arent interested and i still recon that the local Parkes Panthers & Dubbo Demons....yes these teams actually exist....would be able to beat our guys hands down,
At the end of the season what MANAGEMENT should do is to go right thru the roster and training staff,throw out the dead wood....which is most of the team,check the credentials of the coach,go through the rookie list,then get some players who want to respect and play for the BLACK & WHITE and then hit the paddock,play like MEN and not sissies and win a flag in 2006.
This year has been a disaster right from round 1 and there isnt one player who shouldnt be scrutenised...Except Bucks...... and asked the question....do you want to be here in 2006.
I am ashamed to call myself a PIES supporter at present,BUT I must admit that I have been thru thick and thin since 1965 and I recon that there is more to go.

Forget 2005 now and concentrate of PLAYERS and coaching team for 2006.

You know, when i don't watch a game (rarely) i find it would be hypocritical of me to comment on their performance.

So, who the F*** are you make comments about their performance last night and say they played like sissies?

As MM has said, St Kilda played like a Top 4 team and we played like a bottom 4 team....and guess what....... WE ARE A BOTTOM 4 TEAM!

I'm ashamed to call you a pies supporter too, in fact, i don't believe you are from what I've seen you write on here.

Proud Pies · Post by **Proud Pies** » Sat Jul 23, 2005 5:04 pm

molloymagic wrote:If no 1 has said why that st kilda guy got a free kick when Didak and him colided was because Didak put his arms down(channel 9 commentators said if he had kept his arms up then wouldn;t have been a free kick,as it would have been going for the footy).

Keep faith in the pies.

Yes, my Saints loving brother explained this too me this afternoon. Didak realised that they were going to collide, so put his arms down to protect himself and that is why the free was awarded. If he'd kept his arms up, and did more damage to them both, no free would have been awareded.

PeterWH · Post by **PeterWH** » Sat Jul 23, 2005 7:58 pm

Proud Pies.....oooppss sory John Howard.....when you have followed theteam for as long as I have then YOU can be critical.
You are nothing but athe local teams COULD give them a bath and its about time you KIDS that dont remebmber F Wanker....you havent got a clue.
If you cant handle critism then I suggest that you go follow a team like Carlton,where they coulnt win a game is they started NOW.
These fellows arre playing like a bunch of GIRLS the local teams COULD give them a bath and until you realise that the PIES that played in the 60's70's & 80's would make this buch look like kids.
If you are a PROUD PIE then accept the critisism.I suggest that you gp 'get a life' you little worm

Proud Pies · Post by **Proud Pies** » Sat Jul 23, 2005 8:20 pm

PeterWH wrote:Proud Pies.....oooppss sory John Howard.....when you have followed theteam for as long as I have then YOU can be critical.
You are nothing but athe local teams COULD give them a bath and its about time you KIDS that dont remebmber F Wanker....you havent got a clue.
If you cant handle critism then I suggest that you go follow a team like Carlton,where they coulnt win a game is they started NOW.
These fellows arre playing like a bunch of GIRLS the local teams COULD give them a bath and until you realise that the PIES that played in the 60's70's & 80's would make this buch look like kids.
If you are a PROUD PIE then accept the critisism.I suggest that you gp 'get a life' you little worm

perhaps i'm not quite as old as you, and i do like being called a kid, but i didn't realise someone born at the end of the 50s was a kid.........YAYYYYYYYY MEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE

Now, you say, that I can't handle critism, but you've shown yourself to not accept critism at all. When you start to actually make sense with some of your posts and also when you don't critise the team for their game last night when you didn't even watch it, then and only then will i take any of your rants seriously.

psssst, and i do have a life

so don't bother private messaging me with abusive messages again ......i suggest you get over it.

Morrigu · Post by **Morrigu** » Sat Jul 23, 2005 8:51 pm

PeterWH wrote:Proud Pies.....oooppss sory John Howard.....when you have followed theteam for as long as I have then YOU can be critical.
You are nothing but athe local teams COULD give them a bath and its about time you KIDS that dont remebmber F Wanker....you havent got a clue.
If you cant handle critism then I suggest that you go follow a team like Carlton,where they coulnt win a game is they started NOW.
These fellows arre playing like a bunch of GIRLS the local teams COULD give them a bath and until you realise that the PIES that played in the 60's70's & 80's would make this buch look like kids.
If you are a PROUD PIE then accept the critisism.I suggest that you gp 'get a life' you little worm

That is the biggest nonsense I have ever heard!!!

I have been a member for 30 odd years - I go every week and to interstate games - NEVER REPEAT NEVER would I suggest that my opinion of the game, players and the status quo is more important than someone who is younger and follows the same club as I

Time does not quantify passion or committment - just as money does not equal good taste!!!

Yes it is dissapointing to watch us play at the moment - but FFS AFTER 10 minutes you pull the plug and then want to bag everyone

On the whole the effort was better last night againgst some pretty talented bloody opposition - with a hell of a lot of our talent sitting in the stands

The Pies of the 60's. 70s' and 80's may well have been tougher - the game was different then - but they won how many flags??

And yes I was there watching so according to you I should be able to have an opinion

Johnson#26 · Post by **Johnson#26** » Sun Jul 24, 2005 10:48 am

Johnson#26 · Post by **Johnson#26** » Sun Jul 24, 2005 10:49 am

PeterWH, why does age have to be any barrier? Seriously. Everyone has an opinion, and age should be nothing. Anyone who saw the game on TV or live should be able to comment.

Proud Pies · Post by **Proud Pies** » Sun Jul 24, 2005 10:57 am

Johnson#26 wrote:PeterWH, why does age have to be any barrier? Seriously. Everyone has an opinion, and age should be nothing. Anyone who saw the game on TV or live should be able to comment.

Exactly Johnno, anyone who saw the game should be able to comment on the game........those that pulled the plug after 10 minutes have no idea what went on.

Eunos · Post by **Eunos** » Sun Jul 24, 2005 11:01 am

PeterWH has posted?
And its nonsensical rubbish?

I'm surprised!!

This is an unofficial Bulletin Board - owned and run by its users. We welcome all fans of the Mighty Collingwood Football Club.

Post match v Aints...all comments here