Beating the Old Enemy

[Jezza]

A quote from Bigfooty (thanks to Jezza for posting this in the Laugh at Carlscum thread):

I am sick of seeing 15 years of Pendlebury and Sidebottom laughing at us.

Every Collingwood-Carlton match featuring Pendlebury and/or Sidebottom.

Round 7 2007 (Coll 119-95 Carl) = WON (Pendles)
Round 4 2008 (Carl 111-88 Coll) = LOST (Pendles)
Round 12 2008 (Coll 89-119 Carl) = LOST (Pendles)
Round 8 2009 (Coll 53-104 Carl) = LOST (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 17 2009 (Carl 40-94 Coll) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 6 2010 (Carl 102-155 Coll) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 18 2010 (Coll 105-57 Carl) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 3 2011 (Coll 102-74 Carl) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 17 2011 (Carl 79-98 Coll) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 3 2012 (Carl 122-62 Coll) = LOST (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 15 2012 (Coll 62-85 Carl) = LOST (Sidey)
Round 2 2013 (Coll 117-100 Carl) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 15 2013 (Carl 77-118 Coll) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 7 2014 (Carl 70-104 Coll) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 15 2014 (Coll 91-76 Carl) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 5 2015 (Carl 45-120 Coll) = WON (Pendles)
Round 19 2015 (Coll 105-87 Carl) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 7 2016 (Coll 84-99 Carl) = LOST (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 15 2016 (Carl 45-57 Coll) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 7 2017 (Coll 56-79 Carl) = LOST (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 3 2018 (Carl 76-100 Coll) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 14 2018 (Coll 79-59 Carl) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 7 2019 (Carl 87-106 Coll) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 14 2020 (Carl 48-72 Coll) = WON (Pendles)
Round 2 2021 (Carl 85-106 Coll) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 18 2021 (Coll 62-91 Carl) = LOST (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 11 2022 (Coll 79-75 Carl) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 23 2022 (Carl 74-75 Coll) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 10 2023 (Carl 57-85 Coll) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 20 2023 (Coll 76-93 Carl) = LOST (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 8 2024 (Carl 79-85 Coll) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)

[23 YIPPEE!!!]

Definitely got the wood over the blues at the moment and now 3 ahead of head to head

[Johnno75]

3 of the last 4 have been by a goal or less, that must give them nightmares.

[i hate carlton]

Its more satisfying beating them by a goal or less, because the hurt they experience is existential and crippling.

[Jezza]

133-4-129

[Jezza]

Every Collingwood-Carlton match featuring Pendlebury and/or Sidebottom.

Round 7 2007 (Coll 119-95 Carl) = WON (Pendles)
Round 4 2008 (Carl 111-88 Coll) = LOST (Pendles)
Round 12 2008 (Coll 89-119 Carl) = LOST (Pendles)
Round 8 2009 (Coll 53-104 Carl) = LOST (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 17 2009 (Carl 40-94 Coll) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 6 2010 (Carl 102-155 Coll) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 18 2010 (Coll 105-57 Carl) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 3 2011 (Coll 102-74 Carl) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 17 2011 (Carl 79-98 Coll) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 3 2012 (Carl 122-62 Coll) = LOST (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 15 2012 (Coll 62-85 Carl) = LOST (Sidey)
Round 2 2013 (Coll 117-100 Carl) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 15 2013 (Carl 77-118 Coll) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 7 2014 (Carl 70-104 Coll) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 15 2014 (Coll 91-76 Carl) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 5 2015 (Carl 45-120 Coll) = WON (Pendles)
Round 19 2015 (Coll 105-87 Carl) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 7 2016 (Coll 84-99 Carl) = LOST (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 15 2016 (Carl 45-57 Coll) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 7 2017 (Coll 56-79 Carl) = LOST (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 3 2018 (Carl 76-100 Coll) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 14 2018 (Coll 79-59 Carl) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 7 2019 (Carl 87-106 Coll) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 14 2020 (Carl 48-72 Coll) = WON (Pendles)
Round 2 2021 (Carl 85-106 Coll) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 18 2021 (Coll 62-91 Carl) = LOST (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 11 2022 (Coll 79-75 Carl) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 23 2022 (Carl 74-75 Coll) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 10 2023 (Carl 57-85 Coll) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 20 2023 (Coll 76-93 Carl) = LOST (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 8 2024 (Carl 79-85 Coll) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 21 2024 (Coll 84-81 Carl) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)

[piedys]

Its more satisfying beating them by a goal or less, because the hurt they experience is existential and crippling.

And when they don't hurt enough - repeat the process until it does!

3 of the last 4 have been by a goal or less, that must give them nightmares.

Now 4 of the last 5 have been by a goal or less; I'm done with giving them nightmares - I want them in therapy; where they put me decades ago....

[Johnno75]

+4 head to head now, last time that was the case was back in 1972. We got out to -14 back in 2002

[derkd]

Great win last night, congrats to S.P on 400 great games. Nothing less then a legend.

A moment from last night's game perplexes me, and I feel sums up the 2024 season so far.

Elliott kicks the goal, and we have about 17 odd minutes to go.

Carlton gets the ball out of the middle and goes forward. Howe (i think) takes a mark, and a number of Collingwood players around him are seen waves their hands to say (slow down). Why with 17 minutes to go do the players decide to try and save the game? From that moment on everyone goes back into the collective shell, and we hang on by the skin of our teeth (AGAIN). We played so well for almost all the game...I just shook my head somewhat when the siren went.

[piedys]

+4 head to head now, last time that was the case was back in 1972. We got out to -14 back in 2002

That -14 in 2002 stat doesn't feel quite exact; perhaps around 1999?
As we hadn't beaten them since 1994 by that stage.
IIRC, in seasons 2000/2001/2002, we went W1/L1 against them, won both in 2003, dropped both in 2004, then finally started to claw them back from 2005 onwards...

[Piesnchess]

Its more satisfying beating them by a goal or less, because the hurt they experience is existential and crippling.

Those five swarthy lads, the Monday Blues, on Utube, will be spewing, again, not happy campers at all now.

[Jezza]

That -14 in 2002 stat doesn't feel quite exact; perhaps around 1999?
As we hadn't beaten them since 1994 by that stage.
IIRC, in seasons 2000/2001/2002, we went W1/L1 against them, won both in 2003, dropped both in 2004, then finally started to claw them back from 2005 onwards...

Johnno is right. It was 103-4-117 after our first loss to them in 2002.

In 1999, it was -12 and -13.

[GreekLunatic]

Its great beating them its even greater beating them twice a year

[BazBoy]

I disliked them but that turned to hate in 1979 we lost a GF to them by 4 points
In the Age a day or so had George Harris and Malcom Frazer mocking us
That got my blood to boil
So just keep beating them by what score

[Jezza]

Add last night to the collection

Footage of the last two minutes of each of the four games.

Round 11 2022 = Collingwood 79-75 Carlton
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Fy0HtqxW88&t

Round 23 2022 = Carlton 74-75 Collingwood
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3Sk7yFwPNvc&t

Round 8 2024 = Carlton 79-85 Collingwood
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pJtU1gT6M0s

Round 21 2024 = Collingwood 84-81 Carlton
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n0k0ocO3tqs