Post match. Pies wallop Roos - All comments please

Johnson#26 · Post by **Johnson#26** » Sun May 30, 2004 3:38 pm

Good review spoljar. A little harsh on Maxwell though, given he only played about 20 minutes. Think Tarrant was a B or B+. Wasn't great, but very good.

spoljar · Post by **spoljar** » Sun May 30, 2004 3:45 pm

Do see your point on Tarrant and agree there. Probably worked harder than what I gave him credit for.
With Maxwell though, he played 57 minutes and had 3 kicks for 2 clangers. With no tackes I didn't see that he had any impact on the game at all.

Presti35 · Post by **Presti35** » Sun May 30, 2004 4:36 pm

Great post's guys!

Just wondering when O'Bree will be ready to play again and who do you think will be dropped when Presti, O'Bree and Holland return to the side?

maggies2003 · Post by **maggies2003** » Sun May 30, 2004 4:46 pm

Presti#1Fan wrote:Great post's guys!

Just wondering when O'Bree will be ready to play again and who do you think will be dropped when Presti, O'Bree and Holland return to the side?

Also add buckley to that list....

Ins: Presti, Obree, Holland & Bucks
Outs: Maxwell, J.Cloke, R.Shaw & a tough last choice...probably lonie or leon davis..

Presti_is_god · Post by **Presti_is_god** » Sun May 30, 2004 5:00 pm

I feel Jimmy Clement deservs a higher grade as he totally took Drew Petrie out of the game after Cloke went off him.

Post by **Cam** » Sun May 30, 2004 6:05 pm

With taggers though you should add to their stats the difference between the tagged player's average disposals and their disposals on the night.
eg. Harvey normally has say 25 poss. Last night he had 10. Lokan has affected him by -15 possessions. Lokan had 9 on his own, add to that the effect he had on Harvey = 9 + 15 = 24 poss. You don't give 24 poss player a D.

Very scientific.

collingwoodpies25 · Post by **collingwoodpies25** » Sun May 30, 2004 7:13 pm

Excellent that we ran for each other for 4 quarters - well done to the much maligned Rhyce Shaw and Shane Woewoedin - I've bagged those two blokes along with many other posters - Shaw ran hard all night and Woey consistently showed a lot of courage in close! Now I'm really glad to give them a wrap!

Long live Tarkyn Lockyer - his spirit and presence is essential to our success

Please let us teach the Weagles a lesson next week - I couldn''t bear it here in WA if we were to lose!!

The momentum is building!

spoljar · Post by **spoljar** » Sun May 30, 2004 7:49 pm

Cam, an excellent formula for Taggers! Will use that one myself in the future as it is difficult to judge exactly how they have performed.
Harvey has averaged 17.7 disposals per game this year so I think he has been a bit below his best this year. Therefore the net effect for Lokan is about 17 Disposals. D or C, well I guess that's open for debate. Can certainly see your side of the argument!

peter_pies4ever · Post by **peter_pies4ever** » Sun May 30, 2004 9:08 pm

Good to see Ryan Lonie and Dane Swan play good games.

shackleton · Post by **shackleton** » Mon May 31, 2004 12:33 am

Will there be a match up for Presti this week? Weagles have a short forward line!!

Presti35 · Post by **Presti35** » Mon May 31, 2004 1:02 am

shackleton wrote:Will there be a match up for Presti this week? Weagles have a short forward line!!

Good point... Maybe give him another game at Willi and have him back for Neitz?

sq3 · Post by **sq3** » Mon May 31, 2004 9:19 am

Great game and they are starting to look like Lion Cubs - but better - we have ruckmen.

Stretch on Watson - great and Stretches game - fantastic - he improves every minute he is on the ground. Marking around the ground, quick and long handballs, good delivery by foot and kicking a running long goal. This kid is the real deal and this allows the Pies to leave Josh around and ruck the forward line.

Dids will be the next Aka - confidence bordering on arrogance but he can talk the talk AND walk the walk. His speed over the ground is great and he is doing more team oriented things and his game has kicked up a gear. He has the Aka flair for the impossible goals.

C2 has the ability to be better than J.Brown as he already can cover the ground quicker and has very good hands - but his best asset is the aerial body contests due to his rucking work. This kid is a very rough diamond but boy is he going to polish up into a Carey type game breaker and winner.

All the others played great (even Shaw going to the correct spots on the ground when required) and I thought Cole and Lokan did outstanding jobs and that should get Lokan the job on Cus next week as I expect Lica to get 2 weeks.

Taz is really starting to show why he will the best HF/FF in the competition now he needs to learn to use his weight in a different way and not do the undisciplined grabs - do a Carey and just chest them out of the way or to the ground.

BJ and Lonie are on upward spirals in improvement and Woey really put his body on the line when required.

Great team effort and we are well placed with Bux back this week to pluck the Eagles.

pies417 · Post by **pies417** » Mon May 31, 2004 10:18 am

Couldn't agree more Re the didak aka thing i picked up that at the same point in there careers Aka was averaging only 4 posissions a game more and was playing in the middle add the flair and the case is incredibly strong

foreigner · Post by **foreigner** » Mon May 31, 2004 10:23 am

Only hoping that he wouldn't be a ****head like aka with his off field exploits.

pies417 · Post by **pies417** » Mon May 31, 2004 10:28 am

Big Deal Brisbane love Aka if Didak was doing that for collingwood and winding everyone up all the time it would hilarious! Aka is only a ****head because he plays for the legal cheaters!

This is an unofficial Bulletin Board - owned and run by its users. We welcome all fans of the Mighty Collingwood Football Club.

Post match. Pies wallop Roos - All comments please