Pre-Match: Pies V Port - All comments here thanks

[erniedog]

Based on performance, candidates for exclusion are:-
O'Bree, Shaw, King, Richards.

candidates:- Tarrant, Davis, Mullins, McKee.

If Tarrant and Davis are fit, they are mandatory. Assuming Tarrant is not fit, that leaves Davis as Mandatory. King would be ideally suited for the job on S.Dew so would probably remain. Without Primus, Port's rucks are not a threat especially if Brogan is out. Ideal for further blooding Richards with little risk. This would make McKee unlikely.

This would mean either Shaw or O'bree dropped for Davis or O'bree and Shaw dropped for Davis and Mullins or O'Bree and Shaw dropped for Davis and Tarrant.

I would like to see (unlikely) Fraser on wing C.Cloke at ff with Fraser going to ff when C. Cloke relieves Richards in ruck. Fraser has mobility for wing and he and Cloke interchanging would give us some of the required height we need at ff.

[JLC]

In a two horse race that is exceptional value considering we won the last time we played them.

There were definate signs of improvement last week so im expecting a good performance this week.

jlc

[maggies2003]

cam cloke has to do something this week, coz he did nothing last week.. or else it will be back to willy for him..

[maggies2003]

PLAYERS
Backs: B. Johnson S. Prestigiacomo S. Wakelin
Half Backs: D. Swan J. Cloke J. Clement
Centre: S. Woewodin S. Burns R. Shaw
Half Forwards: A. Didak A. Rocca R. Cole
Forwards: P. Licuria C. Cloke S. O'Bree
Followers: J. Fraser, B. Holland, M. McGough
Interchange: M. Lokan, R. Lonie, D. King, L. Davis, B. Kinnear, L. Mullins, T. Walker

in: kinnear, Davis, Mullins

(hopeful) outs: C.Cloke, R.Shaw, D.King

[Donny]

maggies2003, What is that team supposed to be ?

C Cloke at FF and dropped ?

R Shaw on a wing and dropped ?

[Cam]

IN: Davis, Kinnear, Mullins, Walker
OUT: Richards

[scoobydoo]

How lucky is Kinear? Is he going out with Christie?

Why would you drop Richards for THIS game? Port usally plays 2
ruckmen sometimes 3 (and Willy has a bye)

Very strange selectios recently.

Hopefully Shaw, Kinear & O.B don't make the flight.

[maggies2003]

magfan, that is the team list released on thursday by the club... they havent put any outs yet as it is a sunday game... and the outs were wat i predicted,.,

[JLC]

cam cloke has to do something this week, coz he did nothing last week.. or else it will be back to willy for him..

I thought Cam Cloke did very well for his first game. The bump on Bolton alone was one of my few highlights for the year.

jlc

[maggies2003]

im not being too harsh on cam cloke, coz it was his first game, thats y im saying give him a few weeks, and if he doesnt improve....see ya later..

[Cam]

magfan, that is the team list released on thursday by the club... they havent put any outs yet as it is a sunday game... and the outs were wat i predicted,.,

Richards is Out

http://afl.com.au/default.asp?pg=news&s ... eid=146144

[Mick's My Favourite]

Cam Cloke was fantastic last week

why would you drop Richards?

Maybe Cam Cloke is going to play in the ruck

[snow24]

I think this is Rhyce's last chance for a while. Can't understand why no McKee, I thought he played good on the weekend? They must want to see if he can back it up.

[Big T]

Shaw + O'Bree = Loss

Can't keep playing these two, Mullins and Davis a must this week.

[Mick's My Favourite]

Is that the rumour about ************************ her.

Rumours mongering = slander = not tolerated.

2nd yellow card.

LD for the bbmods