Post Match Comments......Stand back, explosives inside!!!!

Daks · Post by **Daks** » Sun Apr 18, 2004 7:41 pm

Absolutely pathetic!... i cant beleive it. we have no depth, no passion, no courage, and an average team list. We are officially FARKED!.

mandy · Post by **mandy** » Sun Apr 18, 2004 7:42 pm

PiesFan wrote:
Cotta: Geez i'm sick to death of people questioning why Cloke gets played in the forward line. The reason being is compared to our other key defenders in Presti, Wakes and Clement he is bloody hopeless at the moment.
That's no reason to play him in the forward line is it? If you think he is hopeless down back, then fine. But that doesnt change the fact that he is even worse up forward?

Wheres he gonna play next, on ball?

Nobody should blame Jason. When he's thrown up forward, then put on the bench, back on down back, put on the bench.....

MM will ruin him in much the same way Shaw ruined Sav.

Give the guy a chance to play where he should and LEAVE him there to settle. Jesus Christ! It's not rocket science! I really don't understand what Mick's doing sometimes....

matm · Post by **matm** » Sun Apr 18, 2004 7:45 pm

SOFT
This bears no resemblence to a tough Collingwood team that we all expect.
Please put in Lonie and Williams.
Lonie, Williams and Cloke need to go to make room for some MEN with ticker.

JLC · Post by **JLC** » Sun Apr 18, 2004 7:47 pm

Jason Cloke should settle down at Williamstown and play four quarters of football and get back to basics. I am still far from convinced on Jason Cloke as a defender, forward or bench player. If his surname wasnt Cloke i dont think the wraps on him would be so high.

jlc

mgh3536 · Post by **mgh3536** » Sun Apr 18, 2004 7:52 pm

ACCOUNTAPHARKENBILITY

Total lack of confidence, waiting instead of attacking.

Too wide into the non exisent forward.

Wouldn't be surprised if big Ant was pumped full of the bear juice today, looked proppy.

Too many waiting for someone else...

mandy · Post by **mandy** » Sun Apr 18, 2004 7:52 pm

matm wrote: Lonie, Williams and Cloke need to go to make room for some MEN with ticker.

And looking at our great depth right now, who would those MEN be??

JLC · Post by **JLC** » Sun Apr 18, 2004 7:57 pm

Based on the reports on LSD it seems that the Shaq player pretty well for Williamstown this week. Maybe he has done enough to get a game this week. Based on his build Shaq shouldnt be scared of putting his body on the line.

All i want is to be able to walk away from the game and say at least they had a red hot go for four quarters and gave it their all and are busting in the guts like us supporters.

Im not so sure that i can say that after todays game.

The other thing that shits me is seeing Cole with his arm around Farmer and having a chat etc. I would hope that the players would have been as gutted as the supporters as opposed to mingling with the opposition.

jlc

burnsy17 · Post by **burnsy17** » Sun Apr 18, 2004 8:00 pm

I've worked it all out... we are a moral club who look down on any forms of discrimination... we have a workplace at the forefront of equal employment opportunity - We employ some men and plenty of women...

Below are the employees of the season thus far:

Rachel Shaw
Andrea Williams
Raeleen Lonie
Alice Didak
Sheryl O'Bree
Sharon Woewodin
Jasmin Cloke

Soft, Soft and Soft - Ladies, if it hurts to put your body on the line, if its too manly a task to throw yourself into contests when you know its going to hurt, if tackling an opponent is secondary to ensuring your own safety is preserved, if slamming an opponent into the turf is not an option as it may affect friendships.... then honestly, please, do us all a favour and take up another proffession - as a member, i dont want you at the club - especially on the pay packets many of you are on.

I wish i was in a job where i couldnt get fired based on my performance....

spoljar · Post by **spoljar** » Sun Apr 18, 2004 8:08 pm

Just had a look at the ladder, and its not bad enough that we are 2nd last, but we also have the weakest attack in the league. Hence the fact that not only do we need 11 more wins to make the 8, but percentage wise, we have to make up about 30% on the 8th placed team.

Go_The_Mighty_Magpies · Sun Apr 18, 2004 8:10 pm

PiesFan wrote:
Why oh why is Cloke up forward again? MM was rumoured to say Cloke played better in the 2002 GF then he did in last years GF.....well maybe because he cant play up forward!

funny that, if my memory serves me right he was suspended after the 02 Prelim and didnt play in the grand final??????

M@®© · Post by **M@®©** » Sun Apr 18, 2004 8:11 pm

Once again so many players are NO WHERE TO BE SEEN ......each week i keep saying the same thing to my self ....Jason Cloke, Richard Cole, Alan Didak, Matthew Lokan, Ryan Lonie,Steven McKee, Shane O'Bree, Rhyce Shaw, Andrew Williams, Shane Woewodin & Leon Davis (didnt play today) JUST DONT GET THE BALL im not one to bag players but enough is enough..... im sick and tired of these players lack of input....... DO we have others to bring in ????? as it amazes me how these players get games when they get 5 possessions a game...... I convinced my fiance (an essendon supporter) to get collingwood memberships , she agreed as she knows how much i love the pies......WELL i felt so embarased on our teams peformance !!!!!!!!! PLZ someone stand up !!!!!!!

collingwoodpies25 · Post by **collingwoodpies25** » Sun Apr 18, 2004 8:13 pm

We have some real mental problems amonst this group of players!!! (maybe residual from grand final losses?)

Why celebrate like winners and point to the crowd when your 5 goals down? (Woewodin, Rocca and Holland!!!)

Woewodin is a disgrace to the jumper and the brownlow medal. He is the softest winner of the medal - no courage at all - Neil Daniher must be laughing his head off!

If we got rid of O'Bree or Lica right now they wouldn't be picked up by any other club - useless!!

As a western australian and a life long magpie supporter I have a theory - Someone is punishing me by allowing the West Coast Eagles to take over my beloved club. MM, now Guy McKenna!!!! Why didn't MM experiment with Frase forward, Rocca to the Ruck etc..

MM's selections during the off season are now costing us!! Wouldn't it be nice to have Rup or Scotland back!! Maybe they just didn't suck up enough to MM or fit into his ideal mould. Football is about results not who's a real nice bloke or gets along real well with the coach!! I don't care if we kill blokes to get a win - I couldn't care less about private lives or who lives an alternate lifestyle (like Rup) as long as when you go out on the park you give your life to get the pill in your hands!!

And gees, the Williams for Adkins swap has really paid off!! And I doubt that McKenna is going to bring any sort of humour to the club like he thinks he is- the guy was a great footballer but a hinderance to developing players around him!! He's going to prove to be a pain in the backside - but we won't be able to be rid of him coz he's MM's mate!!

And what on earth is Rocca's problem? When we really needed him today when we got back to 22 points and he drops uncontested marks!! Although he's a great player, maybe we need to let him reunite with Sav at the end of the year and rebuild a side around a centre half forward who's there when you really need him. We are going to miss Davidson!!

Thank God for Benny Johnson, Frase and Wakelin!!

Daks · Post by **Daks** » Sun Apr 18, 2004 8:16 pm

burnsy17 wrote:I've worked it all out... we are a moral club who look down on any forms of discrimination... we have a workplace at the forefront of equal employment opportunity - We employ some men and plenty of women...

Below are the employees of the season thus far:

Rachel Shaw
Andrea Williams
Raeleen Lonie
Alice Didak
Sheryl O'Bree
Sharon Woewodin
Jasmin Cloke

Soft, Soft and Soft - Ladies, if it hurts to put your body on the line, if its too manly a task to throw yourself into contests when you know its going to hurt, if tackling an opponent is secondary to ensuring your own safety is preserved, if slamming an opponent into the turf is not an option as it may affect friendships.... then honestly, please, do us all a favour and take up another proffession - as a member, i dont want you at the club - especially on the pay packets many of you are on.

I wish i was in a job where i couldnt get fired based on my performance....

HAHAHA.... i think you're being a bit harsh on Woey and Dids though. They are both pretty hard at it.

Cakewalk · Post by **Cakewalk** » Sun Apr 18, 2004 8:16 pm

Andrew Williams should never play AFL football again.

I'll go through the rest of them a bit later.

mandy · Post by **mandy** » Sun Apr 18, 2004 8:19 pm

Go_The_Mighty_Magpies wrote:
PiesFan wrote:
Why oh why is Cloke up forward again? MM was rumoured to say Cloke played better in the 2002 GF then he did in last years GF.....well maybe because he cant play up forward!
funny that, if my memory serves me right he was suspended after the 02 Prelim and didnt play in the grand final??????

Tell me you're not serious???

This is an unofficial Bulletin Board - owned and run by its users. We welcome all fans of the Mighty Collingwood Football Club.

Post Match Comments......Stand back, explosives inside!!!!