Round 8 - Casey vs Collingwood at Casey Fields

[MagpieBat]

Club put the replay up last night:

http://www.collingwoodfc.com.au/video/2 ... st-quarter

http://www.collingwoodfc.com.au/video/2 ... nd-quarter

http://www.collingwoodfc.com.au/video/2 ... rd-quarter

http://www.collingwoodfc.com.au/video/2 ... th-quarter

[thompsoc]

Missed Broomhead, Kennedy and Moloney around the guts today. Borthwick as well.

Played all day with a compromised bench. Moore, Young and Maynard not available in the first, Maynard not in the 2nd, then lost Taylor and Still.

Pendles was missed. Abbott to.

Jamar & Spencer dominated.

Marsh was the pick of our AFL listed players. His run and dash was truly exciting, shame his ball use lets him down. Love to see him tried forward.

Gault good early but faded in and out after that. Clunked some good marks but struggled in the ruck and with the ground ball.

Shaz looks more assured again this week, making progress, still won't kick on the left.

Reid did really well early but lack of match fitness told later in the game.

Moore was rusty but had a couple of moments.

PK didn't have much impact, poor defensively and when you're getting killed on the rebound spread can't afford a player not to be accountable.

Young was hot and cold, needs to learn that he doesn't always need to try and kick the bladder out of the footy.

Best games I've seen from Goodyear and Manteit who weren't dominant but at least contributed across the 4 quarters.

Least impact I've seen Cox have although he did take a couple of nice contested marks.

TA and Dwyer as you'd expect although Dwyer probably a little less damaging than you'd expect.

Good to catch up with JW and meet the infamous Bat and his father.

Yes good summary.
You are useful sometimes Jackcass!

[MagpieBat]

Stats are out (images courtesy of BigFooty user boxy99):





Karnezis 26 disposals and 9 tackles (team leader on both counts).

Not bad...

[swoop42]

Interesting that Scharenberg didn't get credited for a single tackle.

Perhaps still playing cautious with the knee.

[Dave The Man]

Interesting that Scharenberg didn't get credited for a single tackle.

Perhaps still playing cautious with the knee.

What I seen, He does not trust he knee yet

[jackcass]

Interesting that Scharenberg didn't get credited for a single tackle.

Perhaps still playing cautious with the knee.

What I seen, He does not trust he knee yet

Agree Dave, not exactly avoiding contact as we see with some of his contested marking, but opting to play more outside the congestion.

[woftam]

Interesting that Scharenberg didn't get credited for a single tackle.

Perhaps still playing cautious with the knee.

What I seen, He does not trust he knee yet

Agree Dave, not exactly avoiding contact as we see with some of his contested marking, but opting to play more outside the congestion.

Not only that but he isn't kicking on it either as yet.

[roar]

.I worry that young just won't ever feature much again.

Why would that worry you?

[jackcass]

What I seen, He does not trust he knee yet

Agree Dave, not exactly avoiding contact as we see with some of his contested marking, but opting to play more outside the congestion.

Not only that but he isn't kicking on it either as yet.

Yeah, made that observation a couple of time. 1 hail mary disposal of the left against Richmond is the only time I've seen him use it.

[Pies4shaw]

http://www.collingwoodfc.com.au/news/20 ... nd-comment

[Pies4shaw]

Sorry, double.

Interesting that PK played as an inside mid and had 8 clearances. Also that Roc nominated Marsh as his player of the week. Not much to write home about, though, by the looks of it, concerning the other kids.